From Homer teacher Bruce Rife
Submitted by bgmiller on Tue, 2015-10-06 00:00
Alaska Teacher Adventure
What a great day we had today. The first meeting of the Alaska Adventure Learning Workshop started within sight of the confluence or the Russian and Kenai Rivers. We discussed other confluences as well.
Dr. Brant Miller discussed how the Adventure Learning model was a confluence of actual researchers, grad students and professionals interacting with high school teachers and students developing authentic inquiry investigations.
It was a confluence of teachers from three communities of the Kenai Peninsula. Chris and Doug from Kenai, Chris from Soldotna, and myself from Homer, Alaska.
One of the factors that drew me to this project was the fact it is associated with National Science Foundation, for I had been part of an incredible multi-year career changing grant called POLARIS in the late 90s. So I was pleased the fifth teacher from Anchorage was Bob Adkins who had been part of that grant.
At the Russian River Falls, Dan Rinell of UAA, discussed salmon fish habitat and life cycle. We continued our discussion of the day’s guiding question: How do these ecosystem services contribute to the social-ecological systems and relationships present in today’s region of our watershed? The most obvious response was in the way the ecosystem was “provisioning” the commodity of food. This confluence had provided subsistence to people for thousands of years. It is currently one of the economic engines of the Kenai Peninsula as a world class fishery. Discussions of the impact of decreasing snow pact the last two winter in the areas took place as we watched the last silvers pooling at the fish ladder.
After lunch we did water / stream analysis with Marie from Idaho. I had done Colorado River Watch and Kenai Watershed analysis and much of this was review with the exception of the substrate analysis using “Wolman” ?? charts.
We completed our day at historical Kenaitze camp site, approximately 1200 AD, with the Kenaitze and Dr. Alan Boraas. We discussed oral traditions, Kenaitze culture and food preservation technologies that allowed these people to maintain a permanent sustainable culture.
Comments
Cliamte impacts on ecosystem-services
Brant, I am curious. With regards to the impacts of decreasing snowpack and the provisioning of food especially in light of it being an economic engine, is there a prevailing theory on how climate change will impact this service?
Changes in many systems
I found it very interesting that at the K'Beq site Alan discussed that there was a change in the way natives in the area did certain things about 1000 years ago and that historians are not sure what caused that change. Then today Jim from the National Park service talked about how around 1000 years ago there was a forest where the outwash plain of the glacier is today. Could these incidences be related somehow?
Seeing the forest for the fish?
One thing Bruce Rife said that got me thinking is "the most obvious...[eco-service of salmon] was in the way the ecosystem was “provisioning” the commodity of food.” I feel like there are under-considered services that are highly valuable for ecosystems and economic systems. For example, the nutrients released from the spawning salmon will fertilize riparian trees as well as inland trees, resulting in high primary productivity (as Karen mentioned in a in earlier blog comment; go bear poop!). Ecologically, the services are obvious: big healthy primary producers = big healthy consumers (generally speaking). However, the large healthy trees may also improve economic services. Not only do trees supply lumber for construction, they create shade for the forest floor, resulting in cooler temperatures for streams — another service for the salmon (and other aquatic species). This could prove crucial in light of climate change (as mentioned by Eric). Also, the trees reduce runoff and build up of sediments in the river, ultimately maintaining a stable riverine ecosystem.
Have these been topics of conversation on this learning adventure? If so, what do the local people think of the value of trees? What other economic services of ecosystems might be overlooked (after all, I am coming from a “forest-centric” perspective)?
Forest for the trees
We talked about how decomposition of the leaf litter and root stability provides a huge service to the stream systems of this area. Logging is not an industry here, so forest fires and personal use fishery bank erosion was part of the conversation as to how the cycle of the trees changes based on environment changes due to use or misuse. There was conversation on day 2 during the Kenai Watershed Forum time that we discussed mitigation programs that restore riparian areas to maintain a healthy streambank for both social and environmental issues/purposes/services.
Day 2 of the Adventure Alaska Learning class - morning session
We met in Cooper landing in the morning, during which Brandt introduced the essential question of the day: "How can you integrate these social-ecological systems and relationships into your classroom curriculum in a meaningful way for your students?" Roger, from Idaho, then introduced us to some very interesting visualization technology in the form of Salmon Sim. This was a "game" that simulated Sockeye Salmon activity in the Russian River, as well as life cycle stages of Pacific Salmon. With an X-Box (?) game controller, we saw how we could control a particular salmon making its way up the Russian River to spawning grounds, having to maneuver through waterfalls and against turbulent currents without letting energy levels get too low.
Courtney, from Anchorage, then introduced us to the Augmented Reality Sandbox. This had all of the teachers drooling over the highly interactive tool. A projector hooked up to a computer is aimed downwards over an actual sandbox, as well as a rangefinder from an X-Box. Contour lines are projected onto the sand that match the actual contours of the sand. The contours changed as we manipulated the sand into mountains, valleys and volcanoes. Rain could be produced by holding a hand (rain cloud) about 30 cm over the sand. Apparently, software is being developed that would also allow students to see how wild fires would progress up wooded slopes. This seems like a tool that would have inumerable applications in the classroom.
This activity was followed by a talk by Lisa Beranek from the Kenai Watershed Forum. She informed us how the local non-profit organization can help in environmental education as well as aiding teachers to expand their teaching tool kits and resources. We were issued information sheets on general sciece resources as well as professional development opportunities through various local, state and national agencies. All in all, it was a very informative morning.
Fish Egg Development Timing Importance
It was great, today in biology class I was able to refer back to this workshop, yet again, as I talked about how our 'salmon in the classroom' eggs are progressing, when they will progress to what stages of development, how the temperature of streams affects the progress of development, and how PNW salmon are on a different schedule than we are up here in Alaska because our water temperatures are different. This timing is all very important to the way that salmon provide nutrients to or take nutrients from the ecosystem in their life cycle.
There was a great discussion at the russian river trail landing, on the first morning of the workshop, when we discussed how the accumulated thermal units all affect how fast eggs develop. We even reference how the iced-over streams affects the develpment of eggs by slowing metabolism and cell division so that eggs hatch when there is enough, but not too much, stream flow to provide for the fry. I was able to incorporate this discussion into my lesson and talk about the differences between warm-blooded egg development (birds sitting on eggs or why mammals incubate in utero)and cold-blooded egg development (fish, amphibians, reptiles). We begin our cell structure & division part of the year next week and it was a great segway into that topic.